Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante Menu

If you’re browsing the Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante Menu, you’re probably already craving something comforting and classic. Tucked away at 812 N 68th St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213, this spot has built a reputation for hearty Italian-American dishes that feel both nostalgic and satisfying. The menu reads like a greatest hits list - rich pastas layered with house-made sauces, crispy thin-crust pizzas loaded with toppings, and generous plates of chicken, seafood, and steak that don’t hold back on flavor.

What stands out right away is the balance between tradition and indulgence. You’ll find familiar favorites like lasagna and baked pasta dishes bubbling with cheese, alongside perfectly seasoned appetizers that are easy to share but hard to stop eating. Portions are generous, sauces are bold, and everything leans into that old-school Italian comfort food vibe. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual pizza night or a full sit-down dinner with multiple courses, there’s plenty here to settle in and take your time choosing.

Something To Nibble On

Baked French Onion Soup
US$6.00
French Fried Ravioli
US$8.25
Cheese Bread
$
French Fried Mushrooms
US$7.50

House Salads

Octopus Salad
a mixture of iceberg, spring mix, onions, black olives, tomatoes, and seasoned octopus tossed with italian dressing
US$10.00
Conch Salad
a mixture of iceberg, spring mix, onions, black olives, tomatoes, and seasoned conch tossed with italian dressing
US$10.00
Italian Style Salad, “can Be Shared”
a mixture of iceberg, spring mix, onions, olives, green peppers, tomatoes, and mushroom tossed with italian dressing sprinkled with parmesan with pepperoncini and pepperoni
US$8.95
Tossed Salad
a mixture of iceberg, spring mix, tomatoes, carrots, and red onions served with your choice of dressing on the side
US$4.00
Chef’s Salad
a mixture of iceberg, spring mix, ham, turkey, cheese, egg, tomato, and onion served with your choice of dressing
US$8.75

Sandwiches

Philly Cheese Steak
US$9.75
Beef Burger
$
Meatball
US$7.25
Ham & Cheese On Rye
US$7.50

Seafood Entrees

Broiled Walleye
seasoned walleye broiled with butter and lemon
US$14.75
Breaded Lake Perch
deep fried lake perch cooked golden brown and served with french fries, cole slaw, tartar sauce and lemons
US$14.75
Seafood Cioppino
mussels, prawns, sea scallops, clams, and cod stewed in a marinara with fennel and aromatic vegetables. served with a side of mostaccioli pasta
US$15.95
Shrimp Scampi
sautéed shrimp cooked in a lemon, butter, and white wine sauce served atop spaghetti
US$15.00
Mostaccioli Putanesca
shrimp and scallops with capers, olives, and anchovies in a classic sicilian marinara tossed with mostaccioli
US$15.00

Dessert

Italian Cannoli
US$5.50
Spumoni
US$4.50
Simma’s Cheesecake, (slice)
US$5.50
Homemade Cherry Torte
US$5.00
Slice Of Pie
US$5.25
Tiramisu
US$5.50
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available.